אני שאול ליבנה, פסיכולוג קליני, חינוכי, מדריך, מעל 40 שנה.
אני פועל מהקליניקה הנעימה שלי בשדרות עמנואל הרומי בתל אביב.
אני עובד לפי תפיסה אינטגרטיבית/משולבת, ומטפל בכל הגילאים ותחומי החיים.
אני מתמחה בהיפנוזה, שזה אחד מהכלים בארגז הכלים המקצועי שלי.
אני שאול ליבנה, פסיכולוג קליני, חינוכי, מדריך, מעל 40 שנה.
אני פועל מהקליניקה הנעימה שלי בשדרות עמנואל הרומי בתל אביב.
אני עובד לפי תפיסה אינטגרטיבית/משולבת, ומטפל בכל הגילאים ותחומי החיים.
אני מתמחה בהיפנוזה, שזה אחד מהכלים בארגז הכלים המקצועי שלי.
» Non-verbal means to working through in Hypnotherapy: The issues involved in using a Gong and non-verbal methods in Psychotherapy and Hypnotherapy.
J. Shaul Livnay (Weisbrot) PhD
Non-verbal techniques can provide added means to the working through of different issues and themes in therapy. The introduction of a Gong, an exotic instrument with very potent effects upon both the listener and player, in the process of psychotherapy or hypnotherapy brings in many opportunities for change, intensification, breaking of impasses, as well as dangers and complications. The unique and multiple properties of the Gong are described as they are related to their effect upon the listener in therapy. The indications for the use of non-verbal techniques, including the Gong, are discussed, as well as the many issues involved in its' introduction and use within the context of the psychotherapeutic relationship and process.
Through developing a mode of working with the Gong (Livnay, 1995), the whole area of non-verbal techniques was opened up, with it’s many facets for providing further means for exploring and working through issues in therapy. This essay deals with the various issues, complications and complexities, as well as opportunities which are created in the psychotherapeutic process through the introduction of non-verbal methods, including the use of the Gong.
Though the Gong has been widely used in various Asian countries (Indonesia, China, Korea) for at least 2000 years (Simbringer, 1939), only during the last two decades, has it begun to be applied to psychological and medical practice in Western Europe and in the U.S. (Oehlmann, 1990a, Hess, 1999).
Since its incorporation and exposure in the West, the Gong has had a dramatic and almost magical impact, because of its special qualities (to be described below). It has as well led to a tendency to rapidly reaching depth in altered states of consciousness, loosening of boundaries, over enthusiasm and fascination (Oehlmann, 1990a).
Music in Psychotherapy
One may ask why further complicate an already complicated situation (psychotherapy) by introducing yet another variable (music)?
Music has a very powerful and positive effect upon people in general, while it has several specific effects which can have a positive effect upon psychotherapy:
1. It increases the level of arousal ( Berlyne, 1971; Madsen, Greer & Madsen, 1975).
2. It arouses curiosity and promotes exploratory behavior (Berlyne & Borsa, 1968).
3. Selective attention and abstraction are achieved as there is inhibition of sensory information from other modalities (Hernandez-Peon, 1961; Marteniuk, 1976).
4. Positive emotional experience is promoted (Berlyne, 1971).
5. Above all, it leads to affective arousal. The effect seems to be complex and can cause different types of emotional arousal, either more immediate emotional experiences leading to mood/feeling changes, or affective aspects of associative, more cognitively based experiences (Thaut,1990).
The use of music in psychotherapy can have a facilitating effect upon perception, attention and motivation. In the emotional sphere, it can intensify the here and now experience, as well as provide access to associational processes and emotionally meaningful memories. On the other hand, it can provide an escape for both patient and therapist to distant experiences and memories.
Music, through the use of rhythm introduces facets into the therapeutic process which enable one to reproduce the initial mother child relationship. Benezon (1981), contends that Music re-edits the lost mother-child relationship, and provides a means to act out the transference. Moreno (1988) describes different rhythmic practices which lead to "phase locking", "when two or more objects are pulsing at nearly the same time tend to lock in and begin pulsing at the same rate...the rhythm can bring the two (therapist and client) together on a level which is distinct from verbal communication...even more basic and significant." (Moreno, 1988, p. 271). This is also an apt description of the Ericksonian principle of pacing and leading which is an inherent part of modern hypnotherapeutic practice.
Needham (1967) contends that the impact of different percussion instruments has neural and organic effects which provide the foundations of aurally generated emotions. Neher (1961, 1962) in his experiments demonstrated that drum beating could induce symptoms of trance-like behavior. He described three effects:
1. A single beat of an untuned drum transmits different overtones over different pathways in the brain. The resonant sound can stimulate larger areas of the brain than can a less complex frequency sound.
2. A drum beat contains many low frequencies. The frequency receptors for low frequencies are so much stronger than the delicate high frequency receptors, enabling the listener to tolerate low frequency pitches for a longer time before experiencing pain. Thus, more energy can be transmitted to the brain.
3. EEG measurements of his subjects indicated that the typical tempo of tribal drumming was close to the basic rhythm of alpha wave production, while the drumming produced an auditory driving leading to a trance-like state in the subjects (Moreno, 1988).
We are thereby led to the topic which provides the most natural bridge between music, psychotherapy and hypnotherapy: the shaman.
It is quite apt in these times of attempts at integration between the various schools of psychotherapy (Norcross, 1986), to talk about the shaman in various other cultures around the world, because the shaman tended to practice as a bone fide integrative therapist: "the prototypical healing figure a multi-disciplinary practitioner - a holistic healer...he or she naturally integrates all of the elements into practice." (Moreno, 1988).
The shaman is a person who has more visionary abilities than others. He has been defined as a person who enters an altered state of consciousness at will, in order to contact and utilize an ordinarily hidden reality for knowledge and power, to help other persons (Harner, 1982).
The anthropological and ethnographical literature as to the practices of shamans around the world is surprisingly repetitive (see Kiev. 1964; Bourguignon, 1973; & Rouget, 1985 for extensive reviews). A certain pattern emerges, which is repeated across diverse cultures over the globe:
1. The shaman enters a state of trance, very often by having an assistant play a monotonous rhythm on the drums. Often the drumming is accompanied by dancing. The movement and rhythm leads to a frenzy of emotion. (i.e. Stoll, 1904; Murphy, 1964; Fuchs, 1964).
2. Once in trance, or in the shaman's terms, having entered the "spirit world", he or she performs "tricks" of magic (throwing voices, split dialogues, "disappearance and recapture of the head", etc.) to make a strong impression upon the observers. This is designed to raise the probability of acceptance of his subsequent interventions. (Murphy, 1964)
3. The shaman integrates music, art, drama and dance into practice. A holistic model of treatment is used to achieve a patient's total life adjustment (Moreno, 1988). This is done in terms of the adjustment or undoing of either soul loss, object or spirit intrusion, or breach of taboo (Murphy, 1964).
4. In order to reach the spirit world, the shaman must be focused internally and able to be fully concentrated at the task at hand. Music by assistants supports the alpha wave state (see Neher, 1962 above), and also blocks out distracting stimuli.
Eliade (1974) opined that the hypnotically repetitive rhythmic music has a sedating effect upon the left hemisphere, freeing the right hemisphere to function more strongly and "to travel to the spirit world". The rhythmic music also allows the patient to enter a receptive, semi-hypnotic state that reinforces the belief in the power of the shaman as well as of the healing ritual (Moreno, 1988).
The comparison to modern hypnotherapy and psychotherapy is very striking (for an elaborate analysis and comparison, see Bongartz, 1990). It is not implied, on the other hand, that by introducing a gong in the course of psychotherapy, that the therapist becomes like a shaman. Rather, there are common themes in the aims and means of the shaman and integrative hypnotherapist.
The Gong in other societies
As was mentioned at the outset, the Gong has been used in Asian societies for over 2000 years. Most prevalent has been its' use in Bali, Indonesia, as well as in South-East Asia. In these areas, the gong is used by the shaman to call the Gods or spirits, to banish demons, and as a defense against ghosts. The gong is therein used as one of the prime tools in the healing ritual (Simbringer, 1939).
Actually, in these countries the gong plays a role in almost all areas of life, being used in most ceremonies, for baptisms, for communication, hunting, and signaling, as well as for music, as a talisman, and a a sign of prosperity. (Blades, 1970).
Properties and effects of the Gong
The Gong is a circular body of a special mixture of bronze alloy of sonorous metals, usually hand made with hammer blows, into different shapes, each gong being individual, unlike another. Most are flat surfaced, with some having a protrusion around the center. Many are bent inwards around the edges. The Gong in use here are a 36" Paiste Symphonic Gong and a 100cm.Zyldjian Symphonic Gong..
If the focus is brought back to the psychotherapeutic situation, then the properties and effects can be examined from the viewpoint of the patient's experience. Though one thinks of the Gong as a sort of musical instrument one of the group of the Javanese Gamelan (Blades, 1970)), it is characterized by a variety of properties:
First, as one sits facing the gong, one is struck by its visual qualities:
Fixation. It comprises a series of concentric circles of varying shades of gold, bronze and copper, which tend to lead the eye towards the center, as a kind of fixation point with hypnotic effect. The areas between the circles, in the rear resemble a rainbow, which elicit very positive, relaxing associations.
Pendulum. Depending upon the lighting in the room, as soon as the gong is hit, it begins to move and throw off different visual effects of light and shade, and depending upon the way it is hung, at times to move like a pendulum, again with all of the consequential hypnotic effects.
Most apparent, are the gong's auditory qualities
Rhythm. As one strikes it, one tends to fall into a certain rhythm and beat. Within the treatment situation, this often tends to follow a pattern of pacing and leading, where the player at times falls into congruence with body rhythms, breathing patterns of the listener (pacing) and then move to other variations (leading). The rhythms lead to the arousal of primitive, basic temperamental characteristics and approximate a re-accessing to a kind of mothering resonance (see Benezon, 1981 above). Feldman (1991) has described the rhythmic aspects in music therapy along a continuum of stability and variation, as reflecting the capacity of the mother to transform the biological rhythms to emotional differentiation. She contends that a sense of self is promoted through the organization of the experiencing on the continuum of time, as the dialogue develops between mother and child, player and listener. It should be noted that often, the playing is a-rythmical and varied as well (Oehlmann, 1992a).
Resonance. Most striking is the tremendous depth and resonance of the tones which emerge from the Gong. The resultant overtones have a very hypnotic effect, as was described in Neher's (1961,1962) research above. Rapoport et al (2008) examined the overtone spectra of 4 different Gongs, revealing complex spectra which seemed to explain the extraordinary sounds of the Gongs.
Flow. The tones emerging from the gong tend to be continuous, flowing, and eventually fading far off. The various tonal qualities elicit associations which are suggestive of water, flow, parting and separation, death and war. Strobel (1992) found most patients to provide images of either birth (or its symbolic equivalents) or of death. Oehlmann (1990b, 1992b) has been the only one who has systematically studied the emotional effects of varying loudness of playing of the gong. He found that increasing the loudness, in a group situation, led to a polarization of responses (across 9 scales: joy, sadness, aggression, balance, lethargy, stimulation, drama, anxiety, and transcendence) especially for anxiety and aggression, which he interpreted as related in part to personal dispositions. The fading off is suggestive of far away, which elicits far off memories and induces partial age regression. (see elaboration below).
Enveloping. The tones have qualities of wrapping, enveloping contour, which elicits experiences of the mothering functions of being held, covered, protected, and rocked. These again elicit associations of basic and primal origins.
One is basically touched and moved by the vibrations which emerge from the playing.
Arousal. The vibrations have a tremendous arousal effect, which elicits energy, excitement, emotions, aggression, and sexuality.
One rather constricted and schizoid patient was complaining of feeling drained, exhausted, and somewhat depressed after having intercourse with his wife. We began to use the Gong, along with the verbal suggestion about the arousal of energies. The following week, he denied any effect from the experience with the Gong, but subsequently revealed that he had intercourse with his wife every night, without any of the usual aftereffects.
A 12 year old boy seething with aggressive fantasies which were partly related to frustrations because of serious learning disabilities began to slowly increase both tempo and intensity of his hitting the Gong. He began to reach deafening levels. I asked him to imagine whom he was relating to, which increased his hitting all the more, while reporting that he was beating his school principals. This dramatic interlude enabled him to openly express his aggression, and led to a dramatic shift in his behavior in school, as for the first time, he began to channel his energies in constructive directions.
Relaxation. Alternatively, as Oehlmann emphasized, there is a polar effect wherein the vibrations bring the deepest sense of relaxation.
When we exhaust all of the other properties, another yet emerges. Experiencing the Gong gives the impression of something from another world, and in a way that is so. It is a stimulus from the orient. One must then ask what does this impression add to the experience? Rouget (1985) contends that much of the effect of music in possession states in the different societies which he investigated was more cultural than anything else. He disputed Neher's findings (reviewed above) about the physiological effects of drumming. So how can we explain the dramatic impact of the Gong in Western society? Does the impression of it sounding and looking different arise associations of meditation, mountain retreats in the Himalayas? If we don't have the cultural supports and expectations of how to react to a Gong (most of my patients had no previous contact with one, other than the association of being called to dinner!), then it would seem to indicate that the cultural element does not have the primacy that Rouget indicates. This element certainly deserves investigating.
Introduction of the Gong into psychotherapy.
The Gong is very applicable for group work, and has great popularity in the workshop format, where it can prove to be very useful as a catalyzer for the group process. The aim of this essay, however, is to focus upon the uniqueness of introducing the Gong into the process of individual psychotherapy, and to shed light upon the very basic and concrete effects it has upon the process.
What is meant here by using the Gong during psychotherapy? At crucial junctions during the therapy process, when I feel that the timing is right, and the introduction of the Gong would be beneficial, I will then propose and explain my reasons to the patient. In some cases, just the discussion of the possibility has a dramatic effect (see the case described below). At times the suggestion is discussed over several sessions, while at others, it is most brief, and we turn to using the Gong. The Gong may be played by me, by the patient or by both of us (see section on activity and passivity). In the majority of cases, the Gong will be utilized only once or twice, at a crucial junction in the therapy. So what is being described here is a very strategic and potent, but highly judicious and selective use of an instrument, within the course of ongoing and standard technique of psychotherapy. The questions then emerge, with whom, when, and how does it effect the therapy?
Strobel (1992) listed two main indications: Where the symptomatology indicates perinatal involvement (whether expressed in self-destructive behavior, sadistic and or masochistic tendencies, and perversions), or in instances of therapeutic stalemate. Petzold (1989) finds the Gong most useful for work with Neurotics, especially around constriction. Canacakis (1989) has used the Gong in grief work. In addition, I have found it applicable in the following constellations:
Deep relaxation. Whenever deep relaxation is useful or necessary, the Gong can be indicated and extremely efficient This includes anxiety states, and disorders with psychosomatic components.
Age regression. When I find that age regression is indicated, one of the possible means is with the Gong. This is most relevant in cases involving traumas, as the strong tones and vibrations effect a dramatic return to the original source of the trauma. Furthermore, in working with patients suffering from personality disorders, where primal themes have to be re-experienced in the context of the therapeutic relationship and be worked through, the Gong can be very useful during key points, though of course extreme caution and delicate timing are required. (For elaboration of the Gong's usefulness in work with severe personality disturbances, see Moser (1989)).
Intellectual control. In cases where there is too much an emphasis upon intellectualization, over ideation, rigidity and isolation, the Gong can be a helpful means to connect to the underlying emotions.
Psychosomatics. In cases where the body is used to express emotional stress or conflict, the Gong is useful, as it is experienced first and foremost physiologically. The Gong tends to induce imagery very naturally. It is therefore quite simple to channel the direction towards the body parts or functions which are dysfunctional, and to begin to increase the control over the latter.
Post-Trauma. Those having suffered abuse or traumatic experiences are especially susceptible to having the trauma re-emerge while using the Gong. Herein lie the opportunity as well as the dangers of overwhelming or re-traumatizing. The opportunity involves enabling the victim to concretely “strike back” in a dramatic way, more effectively than by other means.
Reservations. Though the applications seem far-reaching, it is vital to emphasize the extreme caution necessary when the use of the Gong is contemplated especially with severe disturbances, with predisposition to regression, splitting, fragmentation, and de compensation. The therapist must have established excellent rapport and trust, must know the patient thoroughly before contemplating the use of the Gong. Furthermore, the therapist must have extensive personal and professional experience in the use of the Gong, before applying it with difficult and sensitive cases. Moser (1989) describes several safeguards which reduce the dangers with personality disturbances.
The Gong's introduction raises a series of issues, and introduces many new variables into the process which have not yet been fully addressed in the literature. Oehlmann (1990a) touched upon some of the dangers, as have Petzold (1989) and Moser (1989).
Introduction of movement.
First and most basically, even raising the possibility of using the Gong in the process of therapy, no less than actually using it, constitutes the breaking of a rigid and static set on different levels. Concretely, there is a departure from the usual seating arrangement, where one or both of the participants gets up to play. This opens up new angles of vision, regard, interaction, closeness or distance, which in turn enables the raising of issues which may have previously been unspoken, about field, body image, perception of the therapist. This factor is especially relevant with rigid and obsessive patients, and has potent effects for those with hysterical traits as well.
During the course of exploring a certain dramatic reaction of a patient to a supportive compliment that had been made in a previous session, he was invited to try to express his feelings by playing with the Gong. He lightly hit it and was immediately overwhelmed by the deep tones. Upon further encouragement, he continued, and suddenly took the mallet in both hands and gave a tremendous swing, releasing a tremendous beat of the Gong (It seemed like an out of the park home run!). As we subsequently discussed the whole process, it turned out that he was momentarily struck by the fact that I was standing close to him, but at his side instead of opposite him. This aroused a momentary spurt of emotions which he channeled to the Gong. This interaction, which lasted all of three minutes provided very meaningful material for several sessions, and led to considerable progress.
Petzold (1989) has described combining movement, dancing and playing the Gong as useful adjuncts.
Upon introduction of the Gong, once the therapist begins to play, he moves into the mode of active "giving, supplying". There is thereby a breaking the set of usual pattern of therapist passivity. This subsequently opens up issues of the ability to receive, to be nurtured, to allow passivity. This becomes especially meaningful with patients using activity as defense against losing control, and/or becoming dependent. At times, it as well leads to issues of who wants to give, and whom is it for, to emerge. Nurturing is especially relevant and salient with the Gong, as the experience is often perceived as inducing regression to infantile or even intrauterine state. As previously noted. Strobel (1992) finds the use of the Gong to be especially indicated in cases where the symptomatology expresses perinatal themes. He contends that the therapist, in playing the Gong, takes on the role of a midwife. Here we can see that Feldman's (1991) aforementioned contentions about music and rhythm being especially helpful to reenter the early mother-child relationship, to be ever so relevant.
The therapist also becomes a co-actor in the Psycho-drama involving re-enactment of significant relationships.This emphasizes a willingness to introduce a dramatic mode into therapy which is under the therapist's control, rather than to be merely limited to the analytic, observer position. Spotnitz (1963, 1976) has referred to the use of the therapist's "acting out" both the unconscious conflict, as well as the suggested solution to the conflict within the therapy session. This is a further aspect of integrating a vital tenet of the Ericksonian approach: The therapist’s perception and grasp of the patient’s unconscious is used to guide him in his approach to the patient, without necessarily interpreting and analyzing the material. The themes are “worked through” as they are played out in the interaction between therapist and patient.
Introduction of novelty.
The moving from the ordinary talking mode to one of playing, alternating playing for and letting the patient play brings with it an element of surprise, novelty and some of the unconventional. Again, it breaks rigid sets of expectations, especially when there is a stalemate in the therapeutic process. Inherent is the suggestion that change is possible, that the unexpected can be a legitimate part of a respectable inventory.
At times, it can bring a patient in touch with his limits as well as fears of the unknown. One rather rigid and driven man was feeling comfortable with himself, but blocked about what he really wanted to do subsequently with a lot of free time. When I proposed that we might be able to examine his question in an unconventional way, through the Gong, he became perturbed and aware with how threatened he was with novelty, and with "shaking things up". He was able to get in touch with stability, and with the realization that he had gone far enough in therapy for now. This enabled us to begin negotiating the terms for meaningful termination, and subsequently to a successful conclusion of therapy. The mere possibility of using the Gong here was utilized to come to grips with inner reality, including limitations.
There is a subtle shift in the therapy towards the primacy of non-verbal interaction. Much of the therapists modeling in his playing expresses subtle suggestions. The fact that therapist and patient move into predominantly non verbal interaction again induces regression to early issues of mother-infant interactions. As the therapist plays the Gong, he himself enters a light state of trance, the kind that Erickson (1977) called the externally oriented interpersonal trance state. This is to be likened to what Moreno (1988) described above the role of the accompanying music in the work of the shaman. The playing sharpens the therapist's being in tune to subtle non-verbal cues of the patient (breathing patterns, relaxing, excitement, etc.), which he can then begin to match in the rhythm and tonal quality of the play, in the form of first pacing, and subsequently leading.
The use of the voice without the use of actual words (vocality, gibberish, nonsensical utterances) leads to the release of emotions as well as insight otherwise not attainable.
The therapist's spontaneous playing.
A closely connected issue is the role of the therapist allowing himself to begin to play spontaneously. This playing has aspects of reflecting unconscious communication and unconscious themes at work in the therapeutic process (dynamics of the patient's personality, transference, counter transference). In a previous essay (Livnay, 1992), I described using spontaneous verbal productions to express the same themes. I have discovered that my playing the Gong serves a similar purpose. As the therapist allows himself to enter the externally oriented interpersonal trance state, he also enables himself to let his unconscious guide him.
"Playing" with the Gong and patient.
Shapiro (1988) has proposed that entering into play interaction with a patient can be a very useful means of providing a corrective emotional experience. Music is only one such mode. It is clear that the introduction of the Gong into the treatment process brings both a playful yet at the same time very serious influence. As both therapist and patient play together, new areas of interaction are opened up.
A 38 year old woman came to therapy following her escape from an abusive relationship. As we began using the Gong, she experienced several age regression to her relationship to her abusive mother. During one of the sessions, I all of a sudden felt an urge to remove my belt! I shared this intrusion with her verbally, whereupon she had an rush of memories of being beaten by her mother with a belt!
Therapist as model.
The activity, spontaneity, novelty which were described above, as they denote a certain departure from the therapist's usual behavior and role, carry an implicit message with suggestive connotation: It is possible to depart from the usual habits and modes of behavior to express unconventional behavior (it certainly is not usual for a therapist to play a Gong in the middle of a session!), to be forceful and aggressive (louder tones) as well as tender and sensitive (soft tones), to be playful, surprising, encouraging. These and many more messages can have a powerful impact upon the patient in the long run. The question arises especially as to how the therapist's activity and behavior affects the transference? My experience has been that it opens up new channels of interaction and generates more material for discussion. Furthermore, it fosters the creation of a very immediate here and now situation which is mutually experienced and shared by patient and therapist, wherein the therapist is a real person, without hierarchy. This is especially vital with patients with personality disturbances. (see Guntrip's (1969, p. 357) emphasis upon the therapist as a real good person). Here it is important to emphasize that especially as there is a departure from the conventional, that it is vital that the therapist be ever so sensitive to both explicit as well as implicit expressions of transferential reactions to the new interactions which have occurred. Gill (1988), in relating to instances of therapist disclosure of counter transferential feelings to the patient, emphasized the necessity to carefully elicit and discern what the patient's reaction is, how he or she experiences the therapist's disclosure, the personal meaning it has? We can substitute behavior for disclosure in the present case. The emphasis here is that beyond the specific effects and reactions which are elicited as a result of the playing of the Gong which have been described by others (i.e. Oehlman, Strobel), there is a whole gamut of very personal and interpersonal feelings elicited about the therapeutic relationship, which provides the therapist with the opportunity for deepening the relationship, for making it both more real (give and take) as well as more archaic (play as developed by Shapiro above; midwife, mother etc.) (Livnay, 1996, 2002). It touches especially upon three of Diamond's (1987) proposed relational dimensions during hypnotherapy: the irrational side of the therapeutic alliance, the fusional dimension, vs. the real dimension.
Dealing with rapidity and intensity
The use of the Gong in psychotherapy very often enables the patient to enter very rapidly into states of age regression, intense emotionality, and abreaction. It is a very powerful tool which provides the therapist with the opportunity to reach depth and relevant emotions. This brings with it the vital necessity of therapeutic responsibility and professionalism. It must be clear that as with any techniques which are integrated into the therapeutic process, that the timing of their introduction, depends upon the level of rapport, trust, stability in the relationship. In that context, the rapidity is buffered by preparation towards the entering into regressive states. The depth of regression thereby opens new facets in the relationship. The therapist has to be prepared to expect beforehand, and must know to handle the phenomena. It must be noted that the experienced hypnotherapist and hypnoanalyst is used to similar phenomena in the course of hypnotic work. The Gong only highlights the dramatic potential.
A 51 year old woman finally decided to discover her real self. She suffered the effects of being the “parental child”, protecting the mother from a violent, narcissistic father. When she started beating the Gong, she had a violent abreaction, as playing loudly reminded her of her mother’s admonitions that she was like her father! The episode enabled to work upon further definition of herself apart from her parents.
Access without verbal mediation.
During the course of working with the Gong, as the patient enters deep levels of trance, the therapist has both to be able to read and to deal with what is going on within the patient, often without verbal mediation. Strobel (1992) contends that the therapist must demand verbal reports from the patient during the course of the work. This is however also a matter of approach, as the experienced hypnotherapist knows how to read ideo-motor signaling (see for instance Cheek & LeCron, 1968), whether it be explicitly elicited from the patient, or whether he interprets the body language and movements so as to gage matters of depth, discomfort, anxiety etc. Here again, the therapist has an added mode with which to respond, and that is through his playing of the Gong, whereby he can reflect as well as answer the body cues which the patient is broadcasting, through changes in rhythm, loudness, intensity, and tonal patterns. I personally find myself reluctant to speak while I play the Gong. My initial experiences with patient taught me that my accompanying verbalizations where at best secondary, and often superfluous as well as distracting to the main stimulus of the Gong. It may be argued that the verbal message affects the left-hemisphere of the brain, while the tones are being processed by the right-hemisphere. Presenting the two simultaneously produces a kind of dissociation which facilitates as well as deepens trance. (See for instance Lankton & Lankton's (1983) technique of simultaneously speaking to each ear).
The addition of vocality.
During periods wherein a patient plays intensely with the Gong, I have considered the value of introducing the use of vocality, in order to enable to further express emotions. In an ironic way, this becomes a parallel to Helen Watkins technique of silent abreaction (Watkins, 1980; extention & elaboration of: Krakauer, 2009) whereby the patient is invited to begin to let out a voice coming deep from the abdomen, without words. I begin to let out sounds in modeling the desired behavior. In reality, no one is able to hear a thing because of the intensity of the Gong.
A young Psychiatrist had many issues of exposure vs. a drive to make fantastic impressions (narcissistic issues). During his beating the Gong intensely, I invited him to let out his real voice, leading to a highly meaningful experience of his connecting to strong emotions of longing attention and feeling ignored.
A further variation of vocality is the use of gibberish or nonsense. The patient is invited to express a certain issue or problem by the use of non-sensical utterances, which have the effect of by-passing logic and judgement, and are thereby more akin to right-brain expression. This is especially effective when working with a couple, whether it be between two spouses, or a parent-child interaction. The gibberish enables the two to be much more spontaneous, joking, playing with each other, while being enabled to express strong emotions in a humorous way.
The experience with the Gong can elicit many different dimensions and urges (to move, dance, recite a poem, draw or paint) . Petzold (1989) has described the introduction of added sensory and creative modalities. It is vital for the therapist to be open to and resonating such strivings on the part of the patient.
Is this hypnosis?
Methodologically, the question may be raised, whether hypnotic induction is involved in the playing of the Gong? The hypnotic qualities and effects of music were described above. It is clear that music is an apt adjunct. If there are formal suggestions, most of them are made before the actual playing, as I raise the possibility of using the Gong. These may be called pre-hypnotic suggestions, and can be very potent, even when proposed during the conversation part of a session.
Oehlmann (1990a) specified trance phenomena alongside the meditative and body effects of the Gong experience. Strobel (1992) contends that the use of instruments in therapy enables the patient to enter the deepest levels of trance along the five stages specified by Erickson and Rossi (1989). He even adds a sixth stage, contending that through playing, the therapist can also ease the patient back out of trance, without verbal suggestions. Petzold (1989) has described various trance-phenomena which are very strongly elicited in the use of the Gong. Heimrath (1989) finds the boundaries between hypnosis and the experiential state of being when listening to the Gong very fluid.
Does the fact that a psychotherapist uses a musical instrument in the process of therapy make him a music therapist? Not quite. I have been asked if I play an instrument. My answer is that I play with the Gong. One of the reasons which I was so taken by the Gong, was that I immediately felt that I could express myself with it, through it, and easily share it with my patients, without having to extensively train them beyond teaching them some basic skills and approach. Am I making music? I am using facets of music such as tones and rhythms, but I remain within the domain of psychotherapy. Oehlmann (1991) emphasized the continued learning to play the Gong, and being true to the Gong. He is both a musician as well as psychotherapist. I emphasize that my main concern is helping my patients, and introducing techniques which can further my understanding of them, and can facilitate my extending that help. This I have found true of the use of the Gong.
The introduction of music into the psychotherapeutic process, in the form of a Gong can bring several benefits; it can open new opportunities for working through, and it can intensify or break a stalemate. On the other hand, it can introduce complexities as well as dangers which require the therapist to proceed with caution, care, and sensitivity in order to reap the full benefits of the opportunities provided by its introduction. This essay has focused primarily upon the very complexities which are introduced into the relationship between patient and therapist and upon the effects upon the very process of therapy.
Benezon, R. (1981) Music Therapy manual. Springfield Ill.: CC. Thomas.
Berlyne, D. (1971) Aesthetics and psychobiology. New York: Appleton Century Crofts.
Berlyne, D., & Borsa, D. (1968) Uncertainty and the orientation reaction. Perception and psychophysics, , 3, 77-79.
Blades, J. (1970) Percussion instruments and their history. London: Faber & Faber.
Bongartz, W. (1990) Die prahistorischen Wurzelen der Trance. Unpublished manuscript. University of Konstanz .
Bourguignon, E. (1973) Introduction: A framework for the comparative study of altered states of consciousness. In: Bourguignon, E. (Ed.) Religion, altered states of consciousness and social change. Columbus: Ohio State Univ. Press.
Canacakis, J. (1989) Gongschwingung und Gongklang in der Trauerarbeit. in Petzold, H. (Ed.) Heilende Klange. Der Gong in Therapie, Meditation und Sound Healing. Paderborn: Jungfermann Verlag, pp.97-114.
Diamond, M.J (1987) The interactional basis of hypnotic experience: on the relational dimensions of hypnosis. International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis 35, 2, 95-115.
Eliade, M. (1974) Shamanism: archaic techniques of ecstasy. Bolligen series 76. Princeton, NJ: Princeton U Press.
Erickson, M.H. & Rossi, E. L.. (1977) Autohypnotic experiences of Milton Erickson M.D. American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis, 20, 36-54.
Feldman, R. (1991) Rhythmicity in the mother-infant relationship: inferences upon the process of verbal treatment, and the process of treatment through music. Lecture presented at the 23rd Scientific Congress of the Israeli Psychological Association.
Fuchs, S. (1964) Magic healing techniques among the Balahis in Central India. in Kiev A. (Ed.) Magic faith & healing: Studies in primitive psychiatry. New York: Free Press, pp.121-138.
Guntrip, H. (1969) Schizoid phenomena, object relations and the self. New York: International Universities Press.
Harner, M. (1982) The ways of the shaman. New York: Bantam Books.
Heimrath, J.(1989) Das Sonogramm der Personlichkeit: Gongs als Modulatoren der Korperenergie. Munich: Hugendubel Verlag, .
Hernandez-Peon, R. (1961) The efferent control of afferent signals entering the central nervous system. Annals of New York Academy of Science, , 8, 866-882.
Hess, P. (1999) Music psychotherapy with archaic sound sources: an innovative method for treating so-called early disturbances. Musiktherapeutishe Umshau: Forschung un Praxis der Musiktherapie, 20 (2), 77-92.
Kiev A. (1964 ) The study of folk psychiatry. in Kiev, A (Ed.) Magic faith & healing: Studies in primitive psychiatry. New York: Free Press, pp.3-35.
Krakauer, S.Y. (2009) The Therapeutic Release of Anger: Helen Watkins Silent Abreaction and Subsequent Elaboration of the Anger Rock. International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis 57, 1, 47-63.
Livnay, S. (1992) The sharing of associative material in psychotherapy and hypnoanalysis: the benefits of a departure from the principle of neutrality. Hypnos, ,19 (2), 25-33.
Livnay, S.(1995b) The Issues of Using a Gong in Psychotherapy & Hypnotherapy. In Kleinhauz et al (Eds) Jerusalem Lectures on Hypnosis & Hypnotherapy. Hypnosis International Monographs 1. Munich: M.E.G, 167-180.
Livnay, S. (1996b) When Erickson Meets Freud: The Therapist Trance and Counter-transference as Resources for the Hypnotherapist. In Peter, B. et al (Eds.) Munich Lectures on Hypnosis and Psychotherapy. Munich: M.E.G. Stiftung. 79-86.
Livnay, S. (2002c) Finding one's place between megalomania and impotence: Reflections on the effects of owning a hypnotic repertoire upon a hypnotherapist's judgement in critical situations in therapy. In Hoodgin C.A.L et al (Eds.) Issues on hypnosis Cure and Care, Nijmegen, 53-64.
Ludwig, A. (1968) Altered states of consciousness: In Prince,R. (Ed.) Trance and Possession states. Montreal: R.M. Bucke Memorial Soc..
Madsen, C., Greer, R., & Madsen, C. (Eds) (1975) Research in music behavior. Modifying music behavior in the classroom. New York: Teachers College Press.
Marteniuk, R. (1976) Information processing in motor skills. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Moreno, J. (1988) The music therapist: Creative arts therapist and contemporary shaman. The Arts in psychotherapy, 15, 271-280.
Moser, J. (1989) Der Gong in der Behandlung fruher Storungen. in Petzold, H. (Ed.) Heilende Klange. Der Gong in Therapie, Meditation und Sound Healing. Paderborn: Jungfermann Verlag, pp.73-96.
Murphy, J. (1964) Psychotherapeutic aspects of shamanism in St. Lawrence Island, Alaska. in Kiev, A. (Ed.) Magic faith & healing: Studies in primitive psychiatry. New York: Free Press, pp.53-83 .
Needham, J. (1967) Percussion and transition. Man, 2, 606-614.
Neher, A. (1961) Auditory driving observed with scalp electrodes in normal subjects. Electroencephelagraph and Clinical Neurophysiology, 13, 449-451.
Neher, A. (1962) A physiological explanation of unusual behavior in ceremonies involving drums. Human Biology, 34, (2).
Oehlmann, J. (1990a) Zum Gebrauch von Gongs und Tamtams als therapeutische Instrumente Umsch, , 11, 224-236.
Oehlmann, J. (1990b) Einige Aspekte der Wirkung von Gongs. Lautstarkeanderung und gefulswahrnehmung. in Behne K. et al (Eds.) Musik Psychologie: Empirishe forschungen-asthetische experimente, 7 Whilhelmshaven: Florian Noetzel Verlag pp., 61-72.
Oehlmann, J. (1991) Personal communication.
Oehlmann, J. (1992a) Personal communication.
Oehlmann, J. (1992b) Empirische Untersuchung zur Wirkung der Klange von Gongs und Tam-Tams. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.
Petzold, H. (1989) Gong-Singen, Gong-Bilder und Resonanz- bewegung als "Sound-Healing". Intermediale Prozesse in der Integrativen Therapie. in Petzold, H. (Ed.) Heilende Klange. Der Gong in Therapie, Meditation und Sound Healing. Paderborn: Jungfermann Verlag, pp.23-72.
Rapoport,E., Shatz, S., & Blass, N. (2008) Overtone Spectra of Gongs used in Music Therapy. Journal of New Music Research, 37 (1) 37-60.
Rouget E. (1985) Music and trance: a theory of the relations between music and possession. Chicago: U of Chicago Press.
Shapiro, M.K. (1988) Second Childhood: Hypno-Play Therapy with Age-Regressed Adults. New York, W.W. Norton.
Simbringer, H. (1939) Gong und Gongspiele. International archive for ethnography. 36. Leiden: EJ Brill.
Spotnitz, H. (1963).The toxoid response. Psychoanalytic Review, 50, 81 - 94.
Spotnitz, H. (1976). Psychotherapy of pre-oedipal conditions New York: Jason Aronson.
Stoll, O. (1904) Suggestion & Hypnotism in der Volkerpsychologie. Leipzig Press.
Strobel, W. (1992) Die klanggeleitete Trance: Eine analytisch orientierte Form nonverbaler Hypnotherapie. Hypnose und Kognition, 9, (1-2) 98-117.
Thaut, M. (1992) Neuropsychological processes in music perception and their relevance in music therapy. In Unkefer R. (Ed.) Music therapy in the treatment of adults with mental disorders. Theoretical bases and clinical interventions. New York: Schirmer Books, pp.3-32.
Watkins, H.H. (1980) The Silent Abreaction. International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis 28, 2, 101-113.